Dealing with self-criticism | Advice for Young People | Jigsaw

Dealing with self-criticism

Dealing with self-criticism

Tuesday, 25 May 2021

Too many of us are quietly, privately, hard on ourselves. We walk around with an inner critic, telling us we’re not ‘good enough’ and never amount to anything.

Sometimes we feel so much pressure to achieve, self-criticism seems like a necessity. Lockdown has kept us cooped up and in many cases with more free time. We may feel especially guilty if we’ve not been ‘productive’.

We’ve all seen people who ‘achieved’ despite the difficulties of the pandemic. Marathons run in backyards, new languages learned, what seems like hundreds of books read. It’s difficult not to compare ourselves and put pressure on ourselves too.

There’s a myth we can hang on to that a harsh inner critic is useful to get where we want in life.

In this article, you will find:

Self-criticism is a very common experience

However, self-criticism is rarely useful. Realising that reduces its influence on you.

The good news is, there is an antidote. First, you need to understand how and where your self-criticism comes from.

Magnified glass on a pink background
Self-criticism often has an underlying theme that we are not enough.

What is an inner critic?

We all have inner monologues. You know that little voice that narrates your life, reminding you to do things and probably warning you not to do things.

When an inner voice gets critical of you and your actions, it can sound sarcastic, angry, disappointed, pessimistic or just mean. Self-criticism often has an underlying theme that we are not enough. Maybe for you it’s not good enough, not smart enough, not pretty enough, not talented enough, not [fill in the blank] enough.

Sometimes self-criticism is so rooted in our way of thinking that we can’t tell the difference between the self-critic and our real point of view. This way the negative thoughts can become facts in our mind.

When we’re in a challenging situation or one that causes self-doubt, our inner critic can escalate. Some young people don’t even realise it’s there.

It’s like talk radio in the background, chattering away, a channel that always seems on. It can get so familiar, they’re not aware enough to stop and question what they’re listening to. Most importantly of all, they don’t change the channel.

Negative self-talk

This animation was developed for us by students in the Institute of Art, Design and Technology in Dún Laoghaire, Co Dublin. It outlines how we can be our own worst enemy with negative self-talk and ways to change that.

The problem with self-criticism

Self-criticism can seem like it’s there to motivate you. At one point, it may have been a motivator and proved to be an effective tool. But if you’re reading this it is more than likely spilling over into other areas of your life and has become destructive rather than constructive.

Maybe you think your inner critic is the voice that will drive you to run faster, study more, try harder, perform better, etc. A motivating, encouraging voice is OK. The problem is when we become overly harsh with ourselves.

Studies show self-criticism can reduce our chances of achieving our goals and can actually slow our progress. Critical self-talk can crush motivation and lead to procrastination. It can slow us down, drain our energy and damage our self-esteem.

When you tell yourself you’re going to mess up, you’re creating a self-fulfilling prophecy. Self-criticism can trip up professionals and even elite athletes too. In a special podcast on ‘choking’, Freakonomics interviewed Jeremy Abbott. He was one of the best figure skaters in the world when he competed at the 2014 Olympics, hoping for a gold medal.

In the middle of his Olympic routine, Abbott fell hard on the ice and gave what the NBC commentator called “a disastrous performance”. He finished 12th and retired shortly after. He told Freakonomics that “the moment I went out… every insecurity that I had about myself and about my skating was just magnified by a million.”

In Jigsaw, we work with young people to listen to and challenge their inner critic.

In Jigsaw, when we support young people who’s self criticism is affecting their wellbeing, we ask them to try understand their self critic better.

Understanding where self-criticism comes from

“You didn’t lick it off a stone” is a great Irish phrase. It means we are influenced by the people around us, those we grew up with and those we share genes with. These days, many of us spend more time on social media which can force us to evaluate or compare ourselves more than usual.

In Jigsaw, when we support young people whose self-criticism is affecting their wellbeing, we ask them to understand their self-critic better. That usually means asking, who does it sound like?

Does it speak like someone who bullied you in school? Does it remind you of an overly critical parent or relative? A harsh teacher? Or someone you had a difficult relationship with?

Early experiences

Some young people find that when they were younger, their parents or a teacher used harsh words to get them to do something. These early experiences leave an impression on them. They think that if they’re really hard on themselves they’ll get things done, or at least make the people around them happy.

Borrowing someone else’s critical words or attitudes and adopting them as our own is called internalising. There are times we have good reason for doing this. It can help us predict an attack, and give us the chance to avert it. Self-criticism can be a misguided way to protect ourselves.

If this sounds familiar, know that you don’t want or need an inner critic to be in the passenger seat for the rest of your life. There are ways to turn down the volume on it. Recognising that it is there and where it came from already reduces its power.

Jigsaw Clinician
We need to learn how to be kind to ourselves and listen to what we're saying to ourselves. Are we saying things to ourselves that we would never say to somebody else?

The great antidote to self-criticism

The opposite to self-criticism is self-compassion.

What is self-compassion?

Treating yourself with kindness and empathy is self-compassion. When a friend is worried or in trouble, we can usually find some kind and wise words to say. The trick is to find those words for ourselves.

Self-compassion replaces the shouty sergeant major with an encouraging coach who cheers you on. The coach recognises your effort and never compares you to others.

Instead of finding fault, the coach says ‘you are doing your best’, or ‘you’re making great progress’. If you would like to improve something but don’t have time, your coach reminds you that ‘you are focusing on more important things right now’.

Practicing self-compassion isn’t permission to give up, let yourself off the hook, or blame other people. Instead, self-compassion is speaking to yourself with a different voice. The voice understands you have flaws like everyone, but are doing your best. It is accepting that each person is a work in progress.

There are ways to tweak how you speak to yourself to be more compassionate.


Phrases to say to yourself
You’ve probably heard of self-confidence mantras or positive affirmations. At first they might sound silly, but we all need them in our arsenal when self-critical remarks start getting us down. Try saying these phrases to yourself using your own name at the start: “You are doing your best” “You’re doing better than you think”


Replace ‘should’ with ‘could’
‘Should’ is a word that can be limiting and leaves no room for compassion or context. Imagine this phrase: “I should have studied more for that exam. I’m such an idiot” Changed to this: “I could have studied more for that exam. But I was so tired from work the day before I couldn’t stay up late to cram. Next time I’ll swap my shift the day before a test”

Other tips for dealing with self-criticism

Take the power out of the voice

When you recognise your inner critic chattering away, don’t tell it to go away. Instead, change its voice to an annoying cartoon character. Make it sound like Donald Duck or Dora the Explorer and it will sound ridiculous. This can make it hard to take what it’s saying seriously.

Challenge the statements

Self-critical thoughts are rarely true, and often overly harsh. When you hear these thoughts, pause, and calmly ask for evidence.

If you think, “I’m a total idiot and will mess up this exam/game/project,” respond with ‘let’s look at the evidence’. On a piece of paper write down all the proof you have that points to failure. Then on the other side of the page, list all the evidence against it. For example, you can list other exams you passed, or the fact you were given this project or place on the team to begin with.

Then sit back and look at the evidence on both sides. That should give you a more rational and clearer view. If there are obstacles ahead, you can now plan how you’ll tackle them.

If you’re too overwhelmed to do this exercise yourself, ask someone to help you.

Recognise perfectionism

If you never meet your goals and are never happy with what you achieve, you could be deliberately setting standards too high to meet. This is called perfectionism. It is a form of self-sabotage and can cause great unhappiness in the long run.

Look hard at the expectations you have of yourself. Are they realistic? Where are they coming from?

Try to break these down and learn to live with flexible expectations.

Young man in red hoodie looking at phone

Further help and resources

You may also like

Copy link
Powered by Social Snap